What do I remember from third grade? Mrs. Bensen, high expectations, authentic feedback on my work, and baseball; that is what I remember. I entered third grade in the fall of 1961. Living just sixty miles north of Yankee Stadium, my summer was spent following Roger Maris and Mickey Mantle chase Babe Ruth's home run record. My dad had seen Ruth and Gehrig play often when he was a boy; taking the train to games with his grandfather. We shared a love of baseball like only a father and son can.
Mrs. Bensen, my third grade teacher, was nothing less than a hall of fame teacher. Close to retirement, but with the energy of a speeding train, Mrs. Bensen had a way of getting all of us to stretch to new heights every day. Good was never good enough and we all loved it. We loved her for believing in us before we believed in ourselves. Not only would she do anything to help us each improve in all of the subjects, but she also expected to turn us all into polite, productive citizens. Mrs. Bensen took responsibility for our academic growth as well as our development of what we now call social and soft skills.
We had twenty-eight in our class and Mrs. Bensen had a capacity to know how each of us was doing in every subject all of the time. She naturally differentiated her lessons and our activities, getting the most from everyone. Her two greatest tools were specific, actionable feedback on our work and her relentless, demanding energy level. She was able to set a pace that worked for the brightest among us as well as those who struggled.
By the time we entered third grade some of us were reading Robert Louis Stevenson, but others had fallen behind grade level in second grade. Mrs. Bensen understood that this was normal, she'd seen it for years. She took it in stride. Her mission was helping us each grow. She knew we could. She knew we would. She created the environment that allowed it to happen. She didn't need summative assessments or unit tests to tell her how we were doing. She always knew because she lived it with us. She knew when to push and when to ease up. It was the most demanding year in school one can imagine and we wouldn't have missed it for anything!
I would argue in any era, more teachers should be like Mrs. Bensen. What makes today different is the message sent by the high stakes tests. In the third grade of today, the student reading Robert Louis Stevenson scores high on the test, while the student who fell behind grade level in second grade scores poorly. Without the high stakes test, Mrs. Bensen's students all felt pride in their personal growth; their individual achievement promoted a growth mindset. With a growth mindset, the student who fell behind is more likely to catch up before seventh grade; albeit maybe not all in one year.
In the high stakes test era, the student who fell behind grade level in reading goes on to the next grade with the stigma of the poor test grade and the fixed mindset despair it promotes. Additionally, the high scoring student may also adopt a fixed mindset, thinking high achievement is fixed so why bother trying to grow. Moreover, the pressure on teachers and administrators for immediate test score improvement leads to a stifling cycle of pre-tests, remediation, post-tests, more remediation, grouping, re-grouping, and all the rest of the latest fads and fixes.
No question, the Mrs. Bensens are hard to find, but they can be developed. It is more likely, though, when the environment supports energy, creativity, low stakes failure, personal growth, and student achievement. Paradoxical as it may sound, the high stakes test environment does not encourage student achievement nor does it encourage authentic teacher creativity.